Ed Sheeran is no stranger to controversy, but the story behind his hit song “Shape of You” is one for the books. From a missed opportunity with Jay-Z to a plagiarism lawsuit, the journey of this chart-topping single has been a rollercoaster ride.
Jay-Z’s Opinion on “Shape of You”
During a recent interview with Rolling Stone, Ed Sheeran revealed that he had extended an invitation to Jay-Z for a feature on “Shape of You.” However, the rapper politely declined, noting that the song didn’t require a rap verse. Sheeran admitted that Jay-Z was “probably right” and praised the rapper’s excellent ear for music.
Sheeran’s Plagiarism Lawsuit
Despite the song’s massive success, it wasn’t long before “Shape of You” landed Sheeran in hot water. In March 2022, he faced a plagiarism lawsuit from songwriters Sami Chokri and Ross O’Donoghue, who accused him of stealing the melody from their 2015 song “Oh Why,” which was released under the name Sami Switch.
In a session at the High Court in London, Chokri and O’Donoghue asserted that Sheeran “incorporates concepts from various sources into his music; occasionally he acknowledges it, but not always,” as reported by the BBC. Sheeran refuted these claims, emphasizing that he had obtained clearance for portions of his songs from numerous lesser-known artists, and firmly stating that he hadn’t plagiarized anything from fellow artists.
In April of the same year, Sheeran emerged victorious in the lawsuit. He shared a video statement on Instagram, expressing his happiness with the outcome but also warning of the damage that such lawsuits could cause to the songwriting industry.
Impact on the Music Industry
Sheeran’s experience with the plagiarism lawsuit raises important questions about the state of the music industry. With thousands of songs released every day on streaming platforms like Spotify, it’s inevitable that some similarities will arise between different tracks. The issue is whether these similarities constitute plagiarism or simply a coincidence.
As Sheeran pointed out, the prevalence of lawsuits like these is damaging to the songwriting industry, as it can discourage artists from collaborating and exploring new ideas for fear of being accused of plagiarism. It also puts a strain on the legal system and can be a costly and time-consuming process for all parties involved.
In conclusion, the story behind Ed Sheeran’s “Shape of You” is one of missed opportunities, controversy, and legal battles. While the song’s success is undeniable, it’s clear that the journey to the top was not without its challenges. The impact of the plagiarism lawsuit on the music industry is a reminder of the need for clearer guidelines and standards when it comes to determining what constitutes plagiarism in music.
